Big Plans for 201 Rutherford Ave (the Old 99): Here’s What Charlestown Needs to Know

Change is coming to a familiar stretch along Rutherford Ave.
A proposed development at 201 Rutherford Avenue would transform a currently underutilized portion of the Bunker Hill Mall into a six-story residential building with approximately 240 units, along with parking, amenities, and upgrades to the surrounding streetscape. The project also includes plans for improved pedestrian connections and a more modern, neighborhood-friendly layout—part of a broader effort to rethink this busy corridor.
This development is just one piece of a much bigger picture. With the City actively working on a long-discussed redesign of Rutherford Avenue, aimed at turning the highway-like roadway into a more walkable, transit-friendly boulevard, the area is poised for significant change in the years ahead. Get more details here.
What Charlestown Preservation Is Saying
The Charlestown Preservation Society is keeping a close eye on the proposal, and they’re encouraging residents to do the same.
In their recent blog post, the group emphasizes the importance of thoughtful planning as development ramps up along Rutherford Ave. While they recognize the opportunity to improve an underused site, they also raise concerns about scale, density, and the fit of new construction within the historic fabric of Charlestown.
They stress that projects like this should prioritize community input, respect neighborhood character, and align with broader planning efforts—especially as multiple developments and the Rutherford Avenue redesign all intersect in this area. The message is clear: growth is coming, but it should be done the right way, with Charlestown’s history and livability front and center. You can read more about this here.
What do you think?
You can read more about this project here.
Maureen Dahill is the editor of Caught in Southie and a lifelong resident of South Boston sometimes mistaken for a yuppie. Co-host of Caught Up, storyteller, lover of red wine and binge watching TV series. Mrs. Peter G. Follow her @MaureenCaught.

Boston Sand & Gravel Sues to Block Charlestown Housing
$50M Boost Moves Next Phase of Bunker Hill Public Housing Redevelopment Forward in Charlestown
Monument Square Landmark District Study Moves Forward — Community Meeting Happening This Week